Home The battle over books
Post

The battle over books

NYPL Books Debate

I just stumbled upon a video of a debate that took place on November 17, 2005 at the New York Public Library on the subject of Google Book Search (formerly known as Google Print) and the lawsuits the project has triggered from the Association of American Publishers. Google plans to scan 15 million books from various libraries, including works under copyright, of which only snippets will be displayed as the result of searches. The AAP contends that to get there, Google has to make digital copies of the books and alleges massive copyright infringement, while Google invokes fair use.

I am not going to summarize the substance of the debate here, but if you have interest in copyright issues, I highly recommend you spend the time (100 minutes, but you can probably skip the first 10-15 minutes of introduction) watching it as the quality of the exchanges was very good.

While the panel included four participants and a moderator, the debate turned into a confrontation between Allan Adler, from the Association of American Publishers, and Lawrence Lessig, from Stanford Law School. I have to say that the AAP has found a smart and articulate advocate in the person of Allan Adler, but what matters in the end is that Mr. Adler is defending the interest of American publishers and authors only, not necessarily the public interest at large, and from that perspective I find myself in total agreement with Mr. Lessig’s broader and more consistent views.

As a side note, this debates takes place in the context of American copyright law, not all the aspects of which technically apply to Europe. But Mr. Lessig mentioned in passing that the EU has so far taken a much more extreme approach in granting rights to authors and publishers. I ask this question: shouldn’t Europe learn a lesson from the US’s experience with lobbies and special interests groups, instead of simply giving in?