
NOTE: This is an English translation of an article in French posted in this blog on October 10, 2005.
A recent article published in 24 heures, a daily Swiss newspaper, mentions the non-smoking campaign recently started by GastroSuisse, the main Swiss federation of restaurants and hotels. This is what the situation is about: for fear of seeing Swiss cantons (Swiss states) pass legislation that would ban smoking entirely in public places such as bars and restaurants (Geneva in particular is discussing such a legislation), which would supposedly lead to a negative impact on their attendance, GastroSuisse has started a non-smoking campaign with the goal of maximizing the number of non-smoking seats in bars and restaurants, while still allowing smoking seats.
GastroSuisse has picked the wrong fight. At the very least, the association is now a good decade late. The world is no longer debating the validity of the studies that have shown that smoking is not only harmful to smokers, but also to non-smokers (passive smoking), and that nicotine causes a physical addiction. This fight has already been fought in the United States, in particular in California (where workplaces have become smoke-free in 1995, followed by bars in 1998, a first) as well as several other American states; in Ireland, where it is prohibited to smoke in closed workplaces (included bars and restaurants) since March 2004; and then in Norway, New Zealand, Sweden, Scotland, and Italy. What is Switzerland waiting for?
Prohibiting smoking in public places such as bars and restaurants can only have an overall positive impact. This is obvious for the health of non-smokers, who now outnumber smokers, but also of course for that of smokers, forced to smoke less or even to stop smoking. A temporary negative impact on the attendance of bars and restaurants is not impossible, but studies done in the United States have shown that the only negative economic impact has been on the tobacco industry itself, a result which is of course correlated with a diminution of the consumption of tabacco. And who will complain about that? Follow this link for more information. In California, a positive impact on the economy has even been demonstrated (I personally tend to avoid or stay less time in smoking places).
For more information, it is a good idea to visit the site of the World Health Organization, which mentions that tobacco “is the second major cause of death in the world. It is currently responsible for the death of one in ten adults worldwide (about 5 million deaths each year). […] Half the people that smoke today -that is about 650 million people- will eventually be killed by tobacco.” We are indeed talking about a plague that must be eradicated.
It is saddening to consider that GastroSuisse fiercely fights for an initiative which, in final analysis, completely ignores not only the health of its customers, but also the numerous studies published on this subject, as well as the path already shown by several other countries. It would be interesting to know what influence tobacco companies have had on the origins of this campaign.
Update: The canton of Ticino as just passed a law prohibiting smoking in public places. This canton therefore becomes a precursor in Switzerland, and we can only hope that other cantons will follow this excellent example, even though a federal law would be the ideal solution.
Comments powered by Disqus.